What is 'extra-musical'?What is the composer critiquing?What are the implications of this?Why are they using this process?Can you hear it in the music?

'Extra-musical' refers to elements or aspects that are outside of the music itself. This could include the context in which the music is performed, the cultural or historical background, the personal experiences or intentions of the composer, or any other factors that are not directly related to the sound of the music.

Without specific information about a particular composer or piece of music, it's difficult to say what the composer might be critiquing. However, composers often use their music to critique societal issues, political situations, or artistic trends. They might also critique the limitations of musical conventions or the music industry itself.

The implications of a composer's critique can vary widely depending on the specific critique and the context in which it is made. It could challenge listeners to think differently about a certain issue, inspire change or action, or simply provoke thought and discussion. It could also influence other musicians and shape the future direction of music.

A composer might use the process of critiquing through their music for a variety of reasons. They might want to express their personal beliefs or feelings, provoke thought or discussion, inspire change, challenge conventions, or simply create something unique and interesting. The process of critiquing can also add depth and meaning to the music, making it more engaging for the listener.

Whether or not you can hear a composer's critique in the music often depends on your knowledge and understanding of the context, the composer's intentions, and the music itself. Some critiques might be expressed through the lyrics, the choice of musical elements, or the way the music is structured or performed. However, other critiques might be more subtle or abstract, requiring a deeper understanding of the music to fully appreciate.