Do successful business people benefit others when making their money, when spending it, both, or neither?

This question is subjective and can vary greatly depending on the specific business person and their practices. However, here's a general breakdown:

1. Making Money: Successful business people can benefit others while making their money. This can happen in several ways. For example, they might create jobs, which can help to reduce unemployment and improve the standard of living for their employees. They might also provide valuable goods or services that improve people's lives or solve problems. Additionally, businesses often contribute to the economy, which can have broader societal benefits.

2. Spending Money: Successful business people can also benefit others when spending their money. They might invest in other businesses, helping to create more jobs and stimulate economic growth. They might donate to charities or causes they care about, directly benefiting those in need. They might also spend money on goods and services, which supports other businesses and their employees.

3. Both: It's possible for successful business people to benefit others both when making and spending their money. Many do both, contributing to society and the economy in multiple ways.

4. Neither: Unfortunately, not all successful business people benefit others. Some might engage in unethical or exploitative business practices to make their money. Others might spend their money in ways that don't broadly benefit society.

So, the answer can be any of the four options depending on the specific business person and their actions.