What are the two ways that a moral argument can go wrong? Give an example of an argument that fails in one of these ways
Question
What are the two ways that a moral argument can go wrong? Give an example of an argument that fails in one of these ways
Solution
A moral argument can go wrong in two main ways:
- Invalid Logic: This occurs when the argument does not follow a logical structure, meaning the conclusion does not logically follow from the premises.
Example: Premise 1: All humans have a right to life. Premise 2: John is a human. Conclusion: Therefore, John has a right to own a car.
In this example, the conclusion does not logically follow from the premises. While it's established that John, being a human, has a right to life, it doesn't logically imply that he has a right to own a car.
- False Premises: This occurs when one or more of the premises (the statements upon which the argument is based) are false.
Example: Premise 1: All dogs can fly. Premise 2: Fido is a dog. Conclusion: Therefore, Fido can fly.
In this example, the argument is logically valid (if the premises were true, the conclusion would necessarily follow), but it's unsound because the first premise is false. Dogs cannot fly, so the argument fails due to a false premise.
Similar Questions
Morality is concerned with the results of wrong action, when done.a.Agreeb.Disagreec.Slightly disagreed.I don't knowe.Not at all
Moral dilemmas are conflicts of duties or responsibilities, solutions must be tailored to the special details of individual circumstances
If you justify A by appeal to B, then justify B by appeal to C, and then justify C by appeal to A, what kind of fallacy have you committed?
Toleration Argument is based on the factual or empirical claim that moral beliefs and moral rules vary from culture to culture. Question 9AnswerTrueFalse
Which of these is the source of ethical behavior?Select one:a.Religionb.Culturec.Lawd.All of the mentionedClear my choice
Upgrade your grade with Knowee
Get personalized homework help. Review tough concepts in more detail, or go deeper into your topic by exploring other relevant questions.