What are some limitations of Newton's Laws of Motion?
Research Question
Academic Insights
Newton's Laws of Motion, while foundational to classical mechanics, have several limitations, particularly when applied to modern physics and complex systems.
Key Insights
- Inertial and Gravitational Masses:
- Newton's laws assume the proportionality of inertial and gravitational masses, which is not necessarily a given and can lead to circular definitions when trying to define mass and force .
- Relativity and Inertial Systems:
- Newton's First Law (Law of Inertia) conflicts with Einstein's theory of relativity, particularly in the context of space-time mixing and remote non-simultaneity .
- Reversibility vs. Irreversibility:
- Classical mechanics, based on Newton's laws, assumes reversible dynamics, which contradicts the irreversible nature of real-world processes .
- Sub-atomic and High-speed Particles:
- Newtonian physics fails at the sub-atomic level and for particles moving close to the speed of light, where Einsteinian physics is more applicable .
- Material and Immaterial Dimensions of Force:
- Newton's concept of force has both material and immaterial dimensions, which complicates its strict adherence to the scientific method of observation and experimentation .
Conclusion
Newton's Laws of Motion are limited by their assumptions about mass, their incompatibility with relativity, their failure to account for irreversible processes, and their inapplicability to sub-atomic and high-speed particles. These limitations necessitate the use of more advanced theories, such as Einstein's relativity, for a comprehensive understanding of physical phenomena.
CRITIQUE OF THE TREATMENT OF EINSTEIN'S SPECIAL THEORY OF RELATIVITY IN ISAACSON'S BIOGRAPHY
Science rules : a historical introduction to scientific methods
A NOTE ON THE DESCRIPTIVE CONCEPTION OF MOTION IN THE FOURTEENTH CENTURY
Multi-barycenter Mechanics, N-body Problem and Rotation of Galaxies and Stars
Avalanche dynamics by Newton. Reply to comments on avalanche flow models based on the concept of random kinetic energy
Analysis of Principles and Applications of Chaos Theory
Domain Decomposition Framework for Maxwell Finite Element Solvers and Application to PIC
Three General Laws of Politics and Government in America (with Apologies to Sir Isaac Newton)
Ethno-physics: The Exploration of Kloso Handicraft as a Local Culture in Rumpuk Village
CFD-DEM Two-Way Coupled Numerical Simulation of Bridge Local Scour Behavior under Clear-Water Conditions
Related Questions
- How do Newton's Laws apply to relativistic speeds?
- What are the implications of Newton's Laws in quantum mechanics?
- How do Newton's Laws fail in extreme gravitational fields?
- What are some real-world examples where Newton's Laws break down?
- How do modern physics theories address the limitations of Newton's Laws?
Upgrade your grade with Knowee
Get personalized homework help. Review tough concepts in more detail, or go deeper into your topic by exploring other relevant questions.