Identify the claim that commits an ‘intensional fallacy’, according to the type-identity theorists.
Question
Identify the claim that commits an ‘intensional fallacy’, according to the type-identity theorists.
Solution
The claim that commits an ‘intensional fallacy’ according to type-identity theorists is the belief that mental states and brain states are not identical because they can be referred to in different ways. This fallacy occurs when one assumes that the meaning or connotation of a term implies a difference in the entities referred to by that term.
Type-identity theorists argue that mental states are brain states, and any distinction made based on different descriptions (intensionality) of mental states does not reflect a true difference in the underlying reality of those states.
In summary, the intensional fallacy arises when one mistakenly believes that the linguistic or conceptual differences between mental states and brain states imply that they are fundamentally different, rather than recognizing that they refer to the same underlying phenomenon.
Similar Questions
True or False: Type-identity theorists believe that we learn about mental states being identical to brain states empirically
Identity refers to those qualities or aspects of a person that links her to a group.a.All of theseb.Physicalc.Identityd.Personal
A(n) is a set of generalized beliefs and expectations about a particular group and its members.
Sometimes one is prone to judge an individual based on one's notion of the category of people they most closely resemble. When this happens, one falls prey to:
_____ are composed of simplistic and often inaccurate beliefs about the typical characteristics of particular groups of people.
Upgrade your grade with Knowee
Get personalized homework help. Review tough concepts in more detail, or go deeper into your topic by exploring other relevant questions.