What can we say about the following statement? "I used apples or vanilla flavoring for my apple pie."

The statement "I used apples or vanilla flavoring for my apple pie" suggests a choice between two possible ingredients: apples and vanilla flavoring. However, the use of "or" indicates that it may not include both ingredients at the same time. This can lead to a few interpretations:

1. Disjunction: The word "or" here can be understood as an exclusive disjunction, meaning the speaker indicates they used either apples or vanilla flavoring, but not both. This may be somewhat confusing because typically apple pie would include apples by definition.

2. Inclusive Interpretation: Alternatively, the statement may be interpreted as an inclusive "or," suggesting it’s possible the ingredient used could be apples, vanilla flavoring, or even both. However, given the context of making an apple pie, it would be more logical to expect apples to be a primary ingredient.

3. Ambiguity: This statement introduces ambiguity since it can leave the audience questioning whether apples were indeed used in the preparation of the pie. It raises curiosity about the completeness of the statement.

In summary, this statement could imply either a limited choice regarding the ingredients or create uncertainty about the actual composition of the pie, particularly since apples are essential for an apple pie. The context is crucial in determining the intention of the statement.